Thursday, May 23, 2024

Rewrite rules

I like rewrite rules. They are simple to understand and easy to implement. If you have a rewrite rule (or a set of them) that makes incremental progress in making an expression "simpler" in some sense, you can keep applying it (or them) repeatedly until you have finished the calculation.

If a function directly returns the result of calling another function, we say that the call is in "tail position". We can view this as a simple rewrite rule. Consider the fact-mul function which computes the factorial of a number n and multiplies it by another number m:

fact-mul (n, m) = n! * m

We can define two rewrite rules for this function. If n is 0, then the factorial is 1, so we just rewrite this as m. If n is not 0, we can rewrite this as fact-mul (n-1, n*m). This translates directly into Lisp:

(defun fact-mul (n m)
  (if (zerop n)
      m
     (fact-mul (- n 1) (* n m))))

The rewrite rule doesn't have to rewrite into the same function. For instance, we can rewrite odd? (x) to even? (x-1) and even? (x) to odd? (x-1):

(defun odd? (x)
  (if (zerop x)
      nil
      (even? (1- x))))

(defun even? (x)
  (if (zerop x)
      t  
      (odd? (1- x))))

Yes, this is bog-simple tail recursion, but somehow it seems even simpler to me if I think of it as a rewrite rule.

Even if you don't have tail recursion, or if you have disabled it, it still works, but the number of rewrites is limited by the stack depth.

No comments:

Post a Comment